/>
 
Subscribe to SkiCanada


  
Nasty or nice, Ski Canada wants to hear from you. Please feel free to send us your questions or comments about the magazine, or anything ski related. Some of your questions may be used for publication. Please keep your scribbling short, 150-200 words maximum, concise and legible. You'll be graded on spelling as well. And don't forget to include your name and postal address or at least the city or town in which you live.

Send your letters to:
email: skicanada@rogers.com





 

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR from Travel Guide 2010 issue

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR from Fall 2009 issue 'Whatever happened to ... ?'

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR from Buyer's Guide 2010 issue

Selected letters from previous issues.

FALLING STARS

As always, I sat down to devour Ski Canada’s Buyer’s Guide 2010 and one article in particular caught my eye. In regards to the “Dropping Records” (Chris Lennon, Short
Turns) article regaling the “world record” cliff drops of Jamie Pierre and Fred Syversen, I
have this to say: I could push my 74-year-old mother off a 120-metre cliff, but that doesn’t mean she can “ski” it! Seriously, if you don’t stick it or if you have to dig yourself out of a massive bomb-hole, then it doesn’t count. Bring back the big-mountain flowy stylings of Kirk Jensen and Andrew Sheppard, because the billy-goating going on out there these days doesn’t impress me much.
ELEANOR CULVER (aka Old-School-Granny- Pants), Calgary

LOST VERTICAL

» In your “Best of Skiing in Canada” feature in the Winter 2009 issue you list the five biggest vertical. However, for the East, you have missed out on the highest vertical drop of them all: Le Massif at 770 metres is much higher than Tremblant at 645 metres. JEAN FRANCOIS SIROIS, Charlevoix, Quebec

» Ignoring the fact that there were only four eastern mountains in your “Top 5 Biggest Vertical,” how could you miss Le Massif, the biggest as well as the best ski mountain in Eastern Canada? That’s a big disappointment, considering that many skiers don’t know what an amazing ski experience awaits them there. CLIFF GENTLE, Toronto

The Ski Canada Research Department must have been in the lodge warming up when that bit went through! Our deepest apologies for missing the biggest in the East. As well, Le Massif has some of the best views and on-hill eating in the country. —Ed.

HELPING THE KNEEDY

» I read the sidebar “Tips for knee-friendly skiing” in Monica Andreef’s knee injury story “Twist and Shout” in the Buyer’s Guide 2009 issue. I’ve been aware of material developed by Carl Ettlinger et al and their work at Vermont Ski Safety for about two years now. I remember articles by Ettlinger and Gordon Lipe about getting the best performance out of bindings back in the 1960s and ’70s. I also remember the crusade they led for antifriction devices to replace stiff plastic risers under the toe of the ski boot to improve the consistency and likelihood of sideways release by the toepiece, bindings that did not require the sole of the boot to be notched, and standardization of boot sole shape and dimensions. Ski Canada can take some of the credit for the approval of this project. As part of the sales pitch for it, I asked the question: “Where can people go to learn how to protect themselves in a fall?” Two articles published in Ski Canada in recent years were quoted: “9 Simple Skills” (Buyer’s Guide 2007) and “Good News for Knees” (Short Turns, Buyer’s Guide 2008). That’s not the primary answer teaching organizations really want to hear, yet today the alternatives are very few in our sport. TERRY ABRAMS, Falling Safely Project Coordinator, CSPS Calgary Zone VP Education

AGE OF MAJORITY

» I’m standing on one of the cattle cars into downtown Toronto going to work and just finished reading Iain MacMillan’s First Tracks, “Who’s in the driver’s seat?”. As a person turning 40 next week, I couldn’t agree more; I spend far more on skiing now than I did 20 or even 10 years ago. As I look for local places to ski in Ontario, I find myself driven to join a private club because of the fear of out-of-control boarders running me over. What happened to the days when the ski patrol kicked people off the hill for being out of control? So not only should equipment manufacturers think about who they market to, so should ski hills. Failure to could mean they end up losing the real revenue stream. BRAD KNIGHT, Mississauga, Ontario

WHEELIE GOOD MEMORIES

» Big props go out to Ian Merringer for his “Go with the Flow” (Spring 2008) piece on mountain biking. The concise, witty article put a knowing smile on my face and provided fresh insight into a sport I enjoy but often fi nish the day with my teeth clenched— so I’ve stuck with my road running. His explanation of mental states, how “just the right level of challenge” can get you “in the zone” was something I hadn’t heard before. And the description of muscles “operating according to the barest of suggestions” definitely brought back awesome memories from my days on the trails around Sun Peaks. Maybe I’ll put on the full-face again and step up my challenge level, in search of Zen. DAYANTI KARUNARATNE, Ottawa

GREAT, BUT MAKE IT BETTER

» Ski Canada is the best in the country but you need to have longer articles on going skiing with more photos and concentrate your stories on equipment (like the ski test) into one issue so we can use it to buy new skis, boots or whatever I’m replacing in the fall. (My cousin Brittany agrees with me.) ADAM CAMPBELL, Richmond Hill, Ontario

POSTCARD FROM PEMBERTON

» You suckers, working so hard on the season’s first issue, you missed the best music festival ever! The Hip were rocking and Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers put on the best show I can remember seeing or hearing—that band is so tight and the sound was right on the note. Sam Roberts was really good too! Jay-Z was shit unless you’re an urban bling bunny dreaming of packing heat. Cold Play was good but their sound didn’t hold up, but they did pop up 25 feet from us on a remote stage. My niece saw God. To have been single (and 21) there would have been a marvelous thing—I am breast desensitized. The Bacardi B Live tent was a Mojito-fueled, gyrating, 3,000-square-foot nightclub complete with indoor waterfalls. No need for bud, it was piped in from all directions. Dee Arclais, Pemberton, B.C.

Sorry to be the bearer of bad news but despite attracting 120 bands and more than 40,000 music lovers to the 2008 Pemberton Music Festival, this summer’s event has been cancelled. We’ve already heard plans are underway to revive the show in 2010 however.





WHO’S FOLLOWING WHOM

In the category of Most Romantic Getaways (“Best of Skiing in Canada,” Winter 2008), where you wrote: “And of course you could always give her diamonds...with a tour of Spanky’s Ladder at Blackcomb. Impress HER even more by waiting at the bottom.” Are you kidding me? My wife can wait for ME all she wants at the bottom of Spanky’s Ladder. I’m never going in. ROB SCHERTZER, Vancouver

THAT SETTLES IT

I just wanted to point out a little mistake in your “Best of Skiing in Canada” issue.

I am an avid skier who grew up in Rossland, B.C. and just wanted to let you know that the Paradise chair is still a triple (although it was run as a double for a large part of the year due to mechanical problems), and the triple chair that was replaced by the non-high-speed quad was the Silverload chair. Unfortunately, the end result is nowhere near as effective as replacing the Paradise chair would have been. It just gives a longer lift ride with more stops that ends in a traverse over to the Motherload chair. The skiing, unfortunately, is not new tree skiing, but unexciting, rolling, beginner terrain. The purpose of this may have been to feed the new “ski-in, ski-out” properties being built. ROWAN KRUYSS, Rossland/Victoria

HUGE HELMET-WEARERS OR HUGE-HELMET WEARERS?

My brother (54) and my mom’s boyfriend (86), who are huge helmet wearers, were trying to explain why I should be wearing one. I handed over your article by Jasper Shealy (“The Science Behind Helmets,” Fall 2008) as proof that there are other opinions out there. People, who are proponents of helmet use, often look at non-helmet wearers as simpletons in need of guidance or delinquents with a devil-may-care attitude.

I’ve been skiing since I was two. This year will be my 28th year teaching skiing, so I’ve seen a few runs in my time. Helmet wearers seem to be sheltered from their environment and other skiers. Many helmets limit visibility and/or hearing. I’ve had too many clients wearing helmets ski into other skiers wearing helmets. People who wear helmets ski as if they are invincible. It may be because they are sheltered from the sounds that let you know you are moving at the speed of light. A physiotherapist friend brought to my attention that a helmet doesn’t protect the brain stem area. And didn’t all ski helmets fail a Canadian test for adequate protection last year? JILL DORKEN, Aspen, Colorado

WHERE’S ERNIE?

I have enjoyed your great magazine for at least 20 years as a subscriber. I think an article about Ernie McCulloch would be interesting to many senior skiers like myself—I am 73. I had the great pleasure of having a lesson from him at Mont Tremblant about 20 years ago. What a treat! I was so psyched up that I have never skied as well before or since. There was about fi ve inches of fresh powder on the Beauchemin and I followed him in his tracks about 15 feet behind as he told me what to do. I never fell once, but I expected to. I got several good tips that I had not heard or read about before. I started skiing in my hometown of Sault Ste. Marie, Ontario, when I was about six. I used to use Marker bindings and I well remember the long thongs. TERRY CARSCADDEN, Lively, Ontario

WARMING TO THE SUBJECT

After reading George Koch’s “Is it all doom and gloom?” on global warming in the Fall 2007 issue, I must say he is in a class all his own. It’s sad that you continue to allow him to use Ski Canada as a venue for his lengthy, misguided, uneducated and unwanted rants. Koch’s writing style is best suited for the tabloids. Please keep him out of Ski Canada in the future. BILL MITCHELL, Montreal

»

Years after the end of the Cold War, a Polish intellectual remarked that, until Pope John Paul II visited Poland and millions turned out to see him, he (the intellectual) assumed he was the only anti-Communist remaining in all of Poland. The government’s propaganda, starting in pre-school and covering every aspect of society, was so successful at presenting a monolith of pro- Communist opinion that most people were convinced that everyone either believed in Communism or was at worst resigned to its eternal domination. After the Pope’s visit, the man realized he wasn’t alone.

I suspect a lot of global-warming skeptics figure they’re the last people in their town, region or province not to believe the propaganda. And that’s probably how the movement likes it. JORGE DUDEK, Toronto

George Koch’s “Is it all doom and gloom?” seemed like an odd addition to a ski magazine, particularly after eastern Canada’s snow drought two years ago and the year before that in B.C. I explored George Koch’s website and was not in the least surprised to see a Calgary address and many articles that would have clearly warmed the hearts of tarsand and oil-industry apologists and their climate-change-denying friends.

As someone who lives at the foot of an Ontario ski hill and has many years of observation of weather and snowfall, I can certainly, along with most eastern skiers, attest that the warming trend here is for real. The resort that I live next to doubled the size of its snowmaking capacity some eight years ago. Had they not done so, at least five or six of the subsequent ski seasons would have been either a write-off or very close to it. Similarly, does Koch think that European ski resorts would have been putting massive resources into snowmaking over the past decade because they couldn’t think of anything better to do with their money? JOHN LOW, Mansfield, Ontario





CHILLY DREAM

» I loved Iain MacMillan’s story about Portillo (“Headin’ South,” Fall 2007). For some reason I have been somewhat obsessed with the place for a few years now, checking the weather weekly, trying to decide which week would be best to visit, and if I could spend an entire week at one resort and not get too bored. It has found a place on my “must do” list, along with driving to both coasts (hit N.S. last summer on my motorcycle!), Mardi Gras in New Orleans, ski western Canada every year, see the Rolling Stones, and a motocross safari in Kenya. However, skiing in summer is a huge desire for me. STEVE SCHOGER, Windsor, Ontario

MISSING PAGES

» I have subscribed to Ski Canada for a number of years and have a magazine rack filled with your ski test issues. I will not pay suggested list price for a ski, and so I visit the CSPS Calgary Ski Sale to pick up one-year-old demo skis. Depending on the category of ski that I’m looking for, I grab the appropriate issues from the last few years and head down. The Ski Canada Test results have enabled me to find a pair of skis every time that met my needs and were perfect for what I was looking for. I have noticed in recent years that the amount of information in the paper magazine has been decreasing with a tag line in the reports to visit the Ski Canada website for the rest of the info. I couldn’t take the website with me to a retail store even if I wanted to pay retail pricing. Please ensure that Ski Canada maintains the full details of the ski tests in the magazines. GLENN DAVIES, Calgary

You’ll be happy to know we’ve printed our Ski and Boot Listings again in this Fall Annual Buyer’s Guide, however, unless we kill every other editorial page, including Letters to the Editor, we just don’t have the space for all the numerical test results. But they’re available online at www.skicanadamag.com —Ed.

REVVIN’ AT REVY» My buddies and I skied Revelstoke for three days, then a month later, back home in Oregon, I spotted your magazine with “Here Comes Revelstoke” on the cover (Buyer’s Guide 2008). I read with great interest and agree wholeheartedly with Steven Threndyle. The mountain is amazing and huge. The fi rst day we racked up more than 60,000 feet of vertical, day two just over 50,000 and our last day we could only muster 40,000. There are many memorable ways down this mountain, from Devil’s Club to Snow Rodeo. These runs go on forever and your legs will be crying uncle way before you see the bottom of the gondola. The best part of skiing Revelstoke is no crowds; you can ski most runs and only see a few other skiers. Yes, we are going back for a week this season— and I have sent in my subscription for Ski Canada. MICHAEL KIRKELIE, Eugene, Oregon

OFF-PISTE OR OFF-SIDE?

» After reading Martin Olson’s Style File “Before you duck the rope,” I was shocked and appalled that under no circumstance was there any mention of the risk involved with crossing the line. As soon as you leave the ski hill boundary, you are in the backcountry and different rules apply. There is no grey area between ski hill boundary and backcountry. There are no methods of avalanche control in the backcountry; you are on your own, so Godspeed. Hope you have a beacon, so they can come retrieve your body. Be prepared. (More than friends and a helmet are needed.) The next time you decide to write such an article, take note that a helmet isn’t the only thing that’s going to save your life—it’s the knowledge underneath it. So take a course, get the gear and don’t be an idiot! KATHRYN WHITESIDE, Calgary

» I couldn’t help but think you missed some key points in “Before you duck the rope.” I once spent an afternoon probing avalanche debris for three bodies that used to belong to people who thought it was a good idea to “duck the rope.” The avalanche was less than 20 metres from a boundary rope. Skiing out-ofbounds requires a lot more than a helmet and a “never say whoa” attitude (the latter has killed people in the past). I see more and more people going into places they shouldn’t be because they just don’t know how dangerous they are. Ropes are there for a reason, and in my mind encouraging people to duck them is irresponsible, to say the least. Maybe Mr. Olson should try digging some bodies out of the snow and dealing with their devastated friends and family before telling people how to ski out-of-bounds. DUSTIN CHRISTIAN, Calgary

Ski Canada has published many articles about backcountry safety, gear, courses, avi contro, the benefi ts of hiring a guide, sad stories, warnings and so on. Martin’s tips on skiing the ungroomed simply add to this subject. Skiing off-piste is an established (and signifi cantly increasing) way of life at ski resorts and we try to keep up with it. But just to clarify, Ski Canada would never encourage skiing a closed run or “out of bounds”—ever. Skiing off-piste, which sometimes involves ducking a rope placed to signify you may (or may not) be leaving a patrolled area, is part of Canadian skiing nowadays. Ducking a rope often involves simply skiing a named and ungroomed run that can be found on the trail map. That said, there is also terrain that is permanently closed, controlled but never groomed or skiable but not patrolled. Again, all of these scenarios are also “beyond the ropes” and their degree of safety ranges widely. Some ski area signage is vague (sometimes on purpose) in differentiating a resort’s off-piste areas, but “closed runs” should be well signed and respected. Ski Canada always recommends that if unfamiliar with the terrain, never simply follow someone else’s tracks, ask the patrol for advice—or hire a guide. —Ed.

GO, JUMBO, GO!

» After 12 years of personally fighting to have Jumbo Glacier Resort built and sitting on the Public Advisory Committee studying the terms of reference for Jumbo, I read George Koch’s article on Jumbo nodding in total agreement (Western View, Winter 2007). The myths the anti-Jumbo zealots have been perpetuating are utterly baseless. They say Jumbo is an environmental disaster and that locals don’t want it. They are wrong on both counts. Jumbo is a way to create more jobs with a fi xed amount of natural resources; it’s the epitome of sustainability. For example, if 500 Jumbo resort employees were instead employed as loggers, how many pristine valleys would be logged each year? Energy projects like windmills fight global warming, yet some environmental groups fight windmills due to irrelevant arguments like aesthetics or impacts on local birds. Similar misplaced opposition with Jumbo.

Despite all this misinformation and 16 years for opponents to raise and prove opposition, they only convinced a tiny minority of locals. The local Shuswap band has gone on record as supporting the Jumbo proposal. The latest review received an equal amount of supporting as opposing responses. Perhaps now people know what is actually being proposed. Well done, Mr. Koch! IAN McKENZIE, Ladysmith, B.C.

THE ABJS OF JIBBING

» I’m 18 and I think you guys run an awesome magazine. I always look forward to the next issue. I would suggest one thing, though. Although you have improved greatly on your representation of the jib culture, you have not yet reached into the realm of skills. As more of a recreational jibber and big-mountain skier, I’m always looking for ways to improve my own personal skills. Much of the time it’s a hard thing to fi nd ways to progressively improve, even when I’m on the hill. Also I have found jib culture is based a lot on assumptions that everybody knows what the different kinds of rails are, what certain tricks are called, etc. It’s not at all my point to blame Ski Canada for this, but you could bring to light many of these things for young, interested skiers who are still not yet in the know. You guys have a great section in the magazine for this sort of thing already called Style File with Chris Lennon. More of these would be great. CLAYTON BERG, Caroline, Alberta





NO BOWLIN’, HUNTIN’ OR FISHIN’ EITHER

» Very disappointed. Your December 2006 issue is nothing but resort-based yo-yo skiing and full of glitzy ads. No indication that it’s just about alpine skiing—no other sports like crosscountry, snowboarding, telemark, bushwhacking, wilderness etc. How about indicating on the cover that it’s very narrow in focus?

GEORGE PRIEDITIS, address unknown

I’m not sure how we deceived you but surprisingly Ski Canada is about skiing, not snowboarding, cross-country...nor bushwhacking. We certainly have our share of off-piste content, including backcountry gear and adventure, just not necessarily in every issue. —Ed.

TOO MUCH REBEL RHETORIC

» I agree with the letters regarding helmet use. I’m not saying that every photo has to have a helmet in it, but given that you encourage people to push boundaries, I don’t see how it would hurt to encourage some common sense once in a while.

My wife and I go skiing at Big White every year and she regularly arranges for private lessons (“Ski at Home,” December 2006). “Biatch”? I’ll be sure to pass that characterization along to her. I’m sure she’ll appreciate it the next time she gets sideswiped by some ignorant little twit who learns to talk the talk from you guys, but learns to walk the walk—um, never? Look, I’m a fan of your magazine. The destination and product reviews are great. The support of our national teams is fantastic. Just try to tone down the ignorant rebel rhetoric a little, please. There are enough people on the mountain who don’t have a clue what they’re doing without you egging them on.

GEOFF EBY, Toronto

FAR FROM MORALLY BANKRUPT

» I get so “sick up and fed” reading all the edletters saying that your mag is politically incorrect or that you don’t promote safety, family values, morals or ethics (Your Run, December 2006). Tell(uride) those dog-breaths that they should take a leap off the next cornice, as skiing has—and always will be—about sex, drums (changed that one after high school) and rock ’n’ roll! Skiing is about attitude and freedom, and while this world seems to be continuing to go “downhill” (ha-ha), it’s refreshing to read about (and see great photos of) the one truly great thing left on this planet—I’m talking skiing, baby—and all the funky, fun and on-the-edge lifestyles and life experiences it is really about!

DON WILLIAMS, Barrie, Ontario

FITS LIKE A GLOVE

» I read your Fall 2007 issue from cover to cover. I can’t count how many times I said out loud, “I love this magazine!” That hasn’t always been the case the last few years. But this issue could have been titled “Ski Canada, Andrea” because it spoke to me. It has me aching for the fi rst snowfall! Many letters have complained of too many articles about the extreme skiing that few of us aspire to, and the hard partying lifestyle that goes with it. But with this issue I sense a shift in direction: cat-skiing for the masses, skiing within a budget, skiing with the family in Europe and summer skiing in Chile. These are all things that I dream of as an avid intermediate skier. I even enjoyed George Koch’s take on global warming (though I expect the next issue of Ski Canada will have a page or two dedicated to the responses to this article alone!)

ANDREA McCARDLE, Mississauga, Ontario





COMMUNITY MINDED

I found a couple of things pretty ironic when I read Raymond Schmidt’s article “Community Centres” in your Winter 2007 issue. I, too, learned how to ski at Chicopee. The names of the tricks all rung a bell. North and Sugar Bowl were also favourites, but I still didn’t mind riding the T-bar on Mic-Mac to avoid the lineups for the chairs. The other ironic part to this article is the ski hill I live near is Salmo. I still get nostalgic every night I’m out there and usually follow some of the kids to see what they’re hittin’. I watch them all go, then show them how to air it out with the back of my skis touching my head (backscracher), all old school like, throw down a perfect landing—well, not always—and ski to the lift feeling like a kid again! (I try not to do this while on patrol.)

My fi ve-year-old son is now learning to ski at Salmo this year and is a member of the Nancy Greene Program. He gets excellent coaching two nights and two mornings by three awesome coaches. All of this is made possible by many of the volunteers. Most of the people who operate the hill are volunteers, and the concession in the lodge is run by the ski racers’ parents with student employees, all to keep the hill affordable for the entire community. We should all take pride in the countless hours volunteers put in to ensure our children and the children of others can grow up with great memories for many years and turns to come.

DUSTY SEFTEL, Salmo, B.C.

DEVELOPMENTALLY CHALLENGED

You seem to have a bone to pick with environmentalists, green fanatics and acolytes. It’s discouraging to see such blatant ignorance from [a columnist] of a ski publication when you berate individuals who want to preserve the national parks. Every time anyone has the audacity to slow a resort plan in a national park, people like you go ballistic. After all, they are national parks; they are not getting any bigger, yet the population is getting bigger, so I would suggest that when the parks start to expand then maybe we’ll have some parity on the green side. Until then, I could call you another silver-spooned frat ski boy, but I will not. You are what you are, a hired gun for the ski industry. Now consider this: If Alcan decided to build a smelter down the road from Panorama or Fernie or Apex, in full view of those environmentally benign condos that dot the ski-scape, I would bet your poison pen would be crying the green card then. You’re lucky that the most angst you can experience are closed ski trails and green acolytes.

PETE STUBBINS, residence withheld

NORTHERN LIGHTS

After reading Doug Sack’s article “North of 60” (Inside Edge, Buyer’s Guide 2007), I would like to add more information regarding skiing in the north. Mount Sima in Whitehorse is not the only skiing facility in the Yukon. There are two other alpine ski facilities here: Mount Maichen, operated by the Watson Lake Ski Club, and Moose Mountain in Dawson City. Since the Watson Lake Ski Club was formed in the late 1960s, it has been the only club in continuous operation in the Yukon. We are blessed with natural snow and wonderful views of the lake, mountains and Liard Valley.

Watson Lake Ski Club had a very active racing program, and its alpine racers represented the Yukon Ski Team at the Canada Winter Games in 1979, 1983, 1987 and 1995. In 1990 the Watson Lake Ski Club and Whitehorse racing club formed the Yukon Alpine Ski Association. For many years we had the honour of being the only sport governing body outside of Whitehorse until the association was moved to Mount Sima. At present, we are trying to renew the racing club, but for the past years we have poured our energies into providing healthy outdoor recreational activities for the families and youth of Watson Lake.

JENNY SKELTON, Watson Lake Ski Club, Yukon College





what's up Ski Canada??

First off, love the mag! Now on the to reason for my writings...

No doubt growing up in Ontario is a tease for skiers. We read the magazines and watch the video's only to dream of big mountain lines and jumps into fluff. Eventually I decided to take advantage of youth and move to Whistler, but moved back years ago to finish school. Returning to the cold Ontario winter after experiencing real mountains out west is tough, but I brought back with me a spirit of exploration. My posse and I grew up skiing the same hills in Collingwood for years. Aside from learning new steez in the park skiing became boring, and i was missing powder big time. The spirit of exploration brought us to parts of our 'mountain' that we'd never been before, and recharged our skiing batteries. One day, we stumbled upon a place our dreams were made of with open glades, cliffs, and best of all powder. We named it 'the backcountry' and tried to keep it a secret for as long as we could. Eventually I realized that sharing a secret like this is more fun. There is something satisfying about putting a smile on someones face, and exposing them to a place in Ontario that no one thought existed. So, I'd like to pass on a message to all those who ski on the small hills of the east: EXPLORE! You never know what you'll find.

Here are some pics that finally prove theres powder in Ontario, you just have to know where to find it! There are more where these came from too.

Greg Sturch

by email March 22, 2008





GLOBAL STORMING

»In his recent column (“Is it all doom and gloom?”, December 2006), George Koch lists a number of skeptics to counter the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report by over 2,000 climate scientists. Koch’s skeptics include: Frederick Seitz, who was born in 1911; William Gray, who doesn’t believe man is involved in global warming; Hans Von Storch, who thinks climate change is a good thing; and Martin Durkin, who compares environmentalists to Nazis. At the end of his article Mr. Koch refers to his website Dr. J & Mr. K. Dr. J is a petroleum geologist who used to work for Husky Oil.

Over the past 60 years, Canada’s average temperature has increased 1.98 degrees, with six of the warmest years occurring in the last decade. Last year, Ontario’s largest ski resort, Blue Mountain, laid off 1,300 workers after closing down its ski operations in the middle of the winter season for the fi rst time in the resort’s 65-year history. Thomas Grandi and Sarah Renner have witnessed the impact of global warming with the cancellation of several World Cup ski races. They aren’t focused on doom and gloom; they are trying to do something about it by being part of “Play It Cool.” I think Ski Canada should take more seriously the threat of climate change to the skiing industry since your magazine won’t sell very well when skiing becomes an extinct sport.

NANCY BIGGS, Ottawa

»I found George Koch’s article to be a thoughtful, well-presented compilation of personal observations and excerpts from various sources that illustrate that there is nothing new about change, and that bad science is more common than generally suspected. Want to see confi rmation that the world is changing? Go to the Interpretative Centre at the Columbia Icefi elds in Jasper National Park. Historical photos show the Athabasca Glacier retreating quickly long before man-made effects would have had a large infl uence.

As to what these changes mean to our small part of the world. In the 10 years I have been involved in the B.C. ski industry, I have seen: • Record amounts of snow (1998-99) • Record thin snowpack due to a persistent (cold) Arctic high-pressure system (2000-01) • Less than normal snowpack with little snow below 1,400 metres (2003-04) • Great snow year if you didn’t mind the Pineapple Express in January (2004-05) • Great snow year with the most snow at 1,000 metres elevation since 1998-99 (2006-07)

Yes, I think we should work hard to minimize our impact on the world and the atmosphere. No, I don’t think exporting cash in carbon credits trading is the way to go.

And if you can stand one more story, this time from The Globe and Mail: the focus of the article was on how the Inuit of Canada’s far north are affected by climate change. The writer related how the rising temperature was melting the permafrost and releasing long-frozen logs, which the Inuit were burning for fi rewood. He never did get around to theorizing how warm it must have been to grow those trees that far north.

TOM MORGAN, Monashee Powder Snowcats, Vernon, B.C.

» George Koch is certainly entitled to his opinions on climate change, but what possessed you to publish them in Ski Canada? If I want to read this kind of misinformation, it’s all too easy to fi nd elsewhere. Please stick to what you do best and leave climate change denial to the “experts.”

JOHN WELLS, Victoria

» Well, George Koch is a global-warming skeptic. I can’t say I’m surprised. It’s consistent with his right-wing, conservative thought processes. And he’s right, he’s an “untrained oaf.” He really should have spent more time reading the scientifi c reports and thinking things through a bit better. He’s embarrassingly silly. I’m surprised and disappointed that you published this article. I have never liked George Koch’s writing and would be quite happy if it disappeared from Ski Canada.

DON HEPPNER, Nanoose Bay, B.C.

» Well done, George Koch! There should be more articles like yours in Canadian magazines. Instead, we are getting a lot of “globull” stories! Keep up the good work.

ANDRE BOGDAN, Calgary

» George Koch starts off by saying his article is “not about whether global warming is happening,” but then goes on to drag out every hoary argument against climate change in circulation—from I had an awesome ski day in April so it can’t be true to quotes from weather forecasters pointing out that Al Gore isn’t a scientist. It’s important to think for yourself, George, but rehashing old debates about temperature graphs, obsessing over debunked documentaries and tracking down dissenting voices doesn’t refl ect free thinking, it refl ects intellectual stubbornness.

For readers who want more information, I suggest these sites: go to realclimate.org for a plain language summary of the scientifi c arguments that climate change is happening, human caused and not good for the planet’s future; for a quick response to arguments against climate change, go to gristmill.grist.org and see “How to Talk to a Climate Skeptic” or newscientist.com for “Climate Change: A Guide for the Perplexed”; and for a detailed review of the fl aws in Great Global Warming Swindle, go to medialens.org and look in the archive for the March 13, 2007, alert.

KEVIN WASHBROOK, Vancouver

» I read George Koch’s latest article in Ski Canada. Is he nuts? He’s gonna get killed by some greenie— gonna get shot with some hybrid gun. Loved every line of the article.

FRED PULLER, Sparwood, B.C.

» Koch’s prose fumes like a glossy 300-pound mass of ordure, oscillating between the sublimely illuminating and the ridiculously offensive. I yearn for it. It’s a fl agrant announcement of the writer’s metamorphosis into a total being, pointing rigidly at the failure of intuition. The glare it casts on a prohibition of angst is nothing short of blinding. It breathes mortality. As the reader, we are compelled to strip away our own layers of awareness, leaving nothing attached to the singularity but fear and commitment. I found the primitive, writhing sinews of this piece to be simultaneously delightful and disquieting. This is not merely art—it is an event. Koch is indeed a fearless and meticulous visionary who knows that his audience must not be only moved, but also removed—relocated and recontextualized in the presence of his work. This is the key! This story must be understood for what its intentions are not—a brutal challenge to the reader, almost a threat in the face of anachronistic corruption.

JEFF TAYLOR, Toronto

Huh? Yes, well, um, on that note, more discussion on the world according to Koch next issue, and I promise, lots of other subjects. —Ed.






Archives  



Horizontal Rule










©Ski Canada Magazine